Press "Enter" to skip to content

Posts published in “Day: October 8, 2026”

My fault

It’s not always about you, Dad, my daughters kindly tell me. And they are so right. So my confession here should be put in context.

The change in District 6 in Idaho was recently discussed in Idaho EdNews.

I live in District 6. I was first elected to represent District 6 in the Idaho State Senate, then when we got redistricted to District 5, I got reelected a couple times. Then I got beat.

Then I served on the Commission that redistricted Idaho after the 2020 census. So all you neighbors out there who wish you had better representation in the Idaho Legislature, you can find my address.

District 6 is about the worst in the state. It includes all of Latah County, then a slice of Nez Perce County, then all of Lewis County.

Idaho laws and Federal rules told us what we should do. We needed 35 legislative districts and two congressional ones.

The law told us to keep legislative districts as equal as possible, avoid odd shapes and minimize the splitting of counties.

This state is oddly shaped.

Our counties are worse.

A third of our population lies in two SW counties.

So we had to draw maps. As we did it became clear to me and the others on the commission that the county I lived in, Latah, would need to combine somehow with some neighbor to form a district.

I was a Democratic nominee to the commission. I drew a map for my county that was beautiful for Democrats. I knew where the Democrats lived. I fashioned a very positive map.

But it was very ugly.

When I first got elected, I just represented Latah County. It was at that time, 2010, a district by itself. I had been the coroner for Latah County for 15 years, a doctor in the community for 17. But there were folks flooding into the state down south and to keep just 35 legislative districts, Latah did not have enough people. So the commission back then added Latah and Benewah County.

I got to learn about St. Maries and Plummer. And Fernwood. And Santa and Emida.

They didn’t learn about me. I always lost Benewah County 3:1. And with Hillary in 2016, I lose.

So now, in 2021 serving as a Redistricting Commissioner, with my ugly, positive map for Dems, I’m facing a problem. It’s good for us, but it’s ugly.

The line circled all of Latah, then came down the slope and caught Lewiston downtown, Normal Hill around LCSC, then cut back to collect Lapwai and then up to Lewis County on the prairie.

It was a true gerrymander.

My Republican colleague asked me to reconsider this map.

Where people live and how they vote, should that be the basis for drawing lines?

I knew the Idaho Constitution and the Idaho law. 17-1506(4).

So I agreed to a different map. We swapped the Democratic Normal Hill for the very MAGA Lewiston Orchards.

People believe what they believe and they live where they live.

So it’s my fault this district, Idaho legislative District Six is no longer a swing district, but a strong Republican one. And I was a Democratic appointee to the Commission.

Here you get to decide if I was a fool for trying to follow the law.

Our President has gotten many states to redraw their maps. Idaho isn’t important to him.

I know it’s not all about me, thank you daughters.

The part of this story that’s the saddest to me is how little I could convince people that didn’t know me up there in Benewah County, even in rural Latah to consider voting for me. That was my true failure.

For this experiment to succeed, we need to persuade. That isn’t about how you draw the lines, but how we talk with one another.