Here we go again, Donald Trump and the MAGA media are taking it out on all Afghan immigrants for the heinous shooting of two West Virginia National Guard members in Washington, D.C. Call it racism, collective punishment, whatever, it is anti-American to blame all members of a nationality, ethnic group or religion for the act of one individual.
There is no excuse for Rahmanullah Lakanwal’s unprovoked shooting of the Guard members and he should answer for his crimes to the fullest extent of the law. Neither is there any excuse for Trump’s vilification of immigrants from Afghanistan, claiming them to be dangerous people who were let into the U.S. without any vetting. That is simply untrue. Rigorous vetting has taken place for all refugees admitted to the U.S. in recent years, including those from Afghanistan. Procedures for admission of individuals who assisted and protected American troops in Afghanistan were even more intense.
Lakanwal was a member of a CIA “Zero Unit” sometimes called a death squad and would not have been admitted without close examination of his suitability. Of more interest is how Lakanwal acted after he, his wife and five young sons arrived in the U.S. in 2021. His behavior was apparently unremarkable until March of 2023 when his life seemed to unravel, becoming severely depressed, isolated and nonfunctional. Having seen similar symptoms in some of my Vietnam brethren who were involved in heavy combat, mental intervention would have been strongly recommended. It is unclear what resources may have been available to him. This would not excuse his criminal acts, but intervention might have helped to avert them.
While Trump has pointed the finger at everyone but himself for this tragic shooting, there is blame to go around. Trump granted asylum to the shooter in April of this year, a year after he began exhibiting troubling mental concerns. And a federal court ruled six days before the shooting that Trump unlawfully ordered the Guard units to Washington.
That needlessly exposed the Guard members to risk.
Trump used the horrific shooting of Specialist Sarah Beckstrom and Staff Sgt. Andrew Wolfe to tee off on all Afghan immigrants, as well as those from 18 other countries. In a Thanksgiving posting on Truth Social, he vowed to “permanently pause migration from all Third World Countries” and end all federal benefits and subsidies for "non-citizens", adding he would "denaturalize migrants who undermine domestic tranquility" and deport any foreign national deemed a public charge, security risk, or "non-compatible with Western civilization." If grandpa posted this kind of screed, we’d send him to a home.
The 19 countries targeted were identified in a proclamation issued by Trump in June. They are all poor countries with non-white populations. Although Trump characterizes them as being potentially harmful to “Americans or our national interests,” none of them are in a position to pose a credible threat to the United States. Of interest is the fact that several nations not on the list do have substantial lucrative business relationships with the Trump family and have been at odds with America’s national interests.
It should not be forgotten that 15 of the 9-11 hijackers were from Saudi Arabia and that Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman Al Saud gave the order to dismember a Washington Post reporter. Trump has agreed to sell sophisticated F-35 fighter jets to the Saudis so they will now have their own aircraft.
Neither is Qatar on the suspect list, even though the country was a supporter of the Taliban during our fight against them in Afghanistan. Qatar funneled billions of dollars to Hamas, funding its attack on Israel on October 7, 2023. And, we can’t forget that their leader generously bestowed upon Trump a $400 million Boeing “flying palace’ that will cost taxpayers up to $1 billion to retrofit. In return, the Qataris will soon be flying fighter jets in and out of Mountain Home Air Force Base.
Experience in Idaho shows that Trump’s scaremongering about refugees is pure demagoguery. Idaho has one of the best-regarded refugee programs in the United States. I’ve met wonderful folks from Afghanistan, Iran, Somalia, the Congo, Laos, Iraq, Myanmar and several other of the countries on Trump’s suspect list. They are honest, humble, ambitious and patriotic additions to their Treasure and Magic Valley communities.
Unfortunately, Trump has reduced America’s refugee program to the lowest level ever–only 7,500 entries are expected this year. They will all be white South Africans.
During his first term, Trump devastated Idaho’s refugee program. After rebuilding it over the last four years, it will be devastated again. We all shall be the poorer for it.
