Here is the first sentence of a press release on October 19 from the United States Department of Justice, Idaho District:
“United States Attorney General Todd Blanche appointed John Shirts as United States Attorney for the District of Idaho, effective October 18, 2026. Shirts was sworn in as U.S. Attorney yesterday by U.S. Chief District Judge Amanda K. Brailsford in a private ceremony.”
Well, no. Not exactly. And the difference is worth pointing out because we may see a lot more of it.
For the last year or so the U.S. attorney for Idaho has been Bart Davis, a former state senator who by widespread accounts did a good job during his two stretches in the post (he also served in it during the first Trump Administration). He left, he said, as a matter of retirement.
When such an opening occurs, whether within an administration or when presidencies change (at which point U.S. attorneys often are replaced), a lengthy process ordinarily ensues. The selection of a nominee is only part of it. The appointment is formally made by the president, but the norm is that a number of people, not least the state’s two U.S. senators, weigh in on the selection. Even before an announcement, there’s usually an extensive FBI review, and a vetting process that can take weeks of work for the (prospective) nominee to gather documents and answer lots of questions.
That’s far from the end, because U.S. attorneys need U.S. Senate confirmation before they can be sworn in. Scheduling for committee interviews, debate and votes can take a long time. Last year, months passed in between the announcement of Davis’ nomination for U.S. attorney and his confirmation, and his was a case involving no conflict or controversy at all; if issues arise, the process can take longer.
Davis announced his retirement on October 7. Shirts, as noted, was sworn in to replace him 11 days later.
Does something seem a little off here?
Let me dispense with one thought up front: This isn’t a personal commentary on Shirts, an attorney who is serving his first term in the Idaho House (his departure from it is expected soon) and has not been a controversy magnet as some members have been. More relevant, he worked for about six years (up to 2024) as an assistant U.S. attorney, focusing on criminal cases in the Pocatello and Boise offices, working in the office he’s now appointed to run. He has, in other words, reasonable qualifications for the post.
But – the Department of Justice to the contrary – it’s hard to see how he’s a U.S. attorney, or rather, a permanent U.S. attorney. And the department declared him a U.S. attorney, no qualification added.
He was appointed (the Department of Justice said) by the attorney general, not the president. He has not been confirmed by the U.S. Senate, and there’s no evidence of an extensive vetting or approval process (such as, where are the statements of support from Idaho’s U.S. senators?).
What’s happening here very likely is something different.
It’s not rare for vacancies in the office to be filled – pending completion of the long-running approval process for permanent appointees – by interim officials serving a much more limited period, who ordinarily are appointed by the attorney general. Something like that seems to be what’s happening. It could be that Shirts has been informally selected for a permanent appointment, and he’s effectively getting the appointment on a temporary basis to give him an early launch into the permanent job later.
But if that’s the case, why not say so? Nothing in the Department of Justice materials (or, it should be said, the news reports appearing afterward) seem to have represented the situation accurately.
This may have broader significance. If Democrats win control of the U.S. Senate for the next term, which seems at least distinctly possible, appointments for many positions needing Senate confirmation may not be made at all, in favor of regular temporary appointments which can be made without it.
Especially if the difference between an interim or permanent office holder is intended to become glossed over.
Bear this little slice of Idaho experience in mind as a new Congress settles in next year.
Share on Facebook







