On September 22, the two major party candidates for Idaho superintendent of public instruction, Republican incumbent Debbie Critchfield and Democrat Becky Sundin Mitchell, appeared at a lively debate hosted by the College of Idaho and Idaho Ed News.
Moderator Kevin Richert of the Idaho Ed News praised them for “working it into their busy schedules,.” and they were scheduled to meet again on October 12.
After the first debate, Critchfield backed out of the second appearance, saying a minor party candidate should not be excluded from the event (though that did happen, reasonably, in the first debate). Then the organizers of debate 2 agreed to include the third contender, and Critchfield said her participation was back on.
And that's good. But the tenuousness of it adds another layer to a comment by Richert that “debates have become kind of a lost art in Idaho politics.”
Indeed they have.
The diminished numbers of political debates in recent years has been a nationwide phenomenon, but it hasn’t hit equally everywhere. During this season approaching the general election I like to watch candidate debates around the country, and online and on cable I’ve watched hot battles like the Senate contests in Iowa, Michigan and Maine, and tough U.S. House races like one in Washington’s 3rd district. (They can be great entertainment, as well as being informative about the people and about a broad range of issues.) I’ve watched two debates between the major party candidates for governor in Oregon -- that’s just the first two of the four the candidates have agreed to. Debates remain alive and well in many places.
But in Idaho, not so much, especially at the top.
In the past, the blame for missed debates - and some have been - could be spread around. In 2016, for example, I wrote about how “all three Democratic congressional candidates missed the deadline for filing is unclear. The Idaho Debates organization, which includes people from Idaho Public Television, the League of Women Voters and the Idaho Press Club, for years have been the organizers of the state’s only statewide debate series; the filings they require are intended among other things to show that the candidates involved are running serious campaigns.”
But this year, it’s mostly entrenched incumbents for several top offices including governor (Republican Brad Little) and senator (Republican Jim Risch) who simply took a pass on participating. Both, in fact, seem to be running campaigns that focus on keeping their heads down and replying on their party label to glide back into office in November.
Challengers have tended to press for debates. Risch’s challenger, Todd Achilles, once approached him personally on the subject: “I tried to have a quick conversation with Risch before the event to ask him why he won’t debate me, and Sen. Risch refused to answer the question and just walked away.”
The League of Women Voters held a debate on October 6 for governor candidates, but Little declined to appear.
(Ironically, back in their state legislative days both Risch and Little were known as strong floor debaters.)
It may be a useful campaign strategy. But it doesn’t help the public make an intelligent, informed decision on the ballot.
The problem the rest of us have is that there’s little incentive for the nominee of a majority party in a one-party state to expose themselves to the risk a debate always entails, as long as there’s no price to pay in opting out.
Voters haven’t been penalizing candidates, incumbents or not, for failing to make themselves available to questioning by their opponents in the general public.
They should. Failure of a candidate to showup and participate in debates and other open-public events ought to be harshly penalized by voters.
They’ll change their ways if it starts costing them a few elections. Until then, the incentives call for shutting themselves off from the public, which is no way to run our kind of government.

