Press "Enter" to skip to content

Posts published in “Day: April 7, 2011”

ID: Notes on a sine die

A few notes on the adjournment for the year of the Idaho Legislature.

In an editorial titled "And in the end, hysteria triumphs in Idaho Legislature," the (traditionally conservative) Twin Falls Times-News notes an online poll run on the blog of the (generally conservative) Dave Oliveria of the Spokane Spokesman-Review: “What scares you more: the Idaho Legislature in the Statehouse or wolves in the forest?” Legislature 74%, wolves 10%.

The editorial concluded that "our Legislature has completely abandoned reasoned discourse. Under every speaker of the House and president of the Senate we can think of — extending back to Pete Cenarrusa and Jack Murphy — lawmakers took pride in not wasting their constituents’ money on hysterical nonsense. That’s not the case anymore."

It was, after all, a session dominated by such subjects as federal law nullification, allowing guns on campus, radical and high-speed changes in the public school system and deep stabs at the state's already weak unions, and dismembering of basic health and social services relied on by tens of thousands (if not hundreds of thousands) of Idahoans. In which the ending was spiced by birtherism and Obama-is-a-Muslim talk (described by the legislators involved as, you know, just a joke).

Right toward the end, on Tuesday, there was Senate Bill 1165, which bans abortion for any reason (other than the life or physical health of the mother) at the 20-week mark; no exception for rape or incest. Having already passed the Senate 24-10, it was on the House floor for final action. It passed there 54-14.

One of the speakers in opposition was Representative John Rusche, D-Lewiston, a retired pediatrician - speaking, then, with some professional expertise - who offered a number of arguments against, one of the most central being this: Determination of severe fetal problems and deformities, often at the point of not allowing a fetus to be carried to term, aren't usually made until then. "These diagnoses were made right at about 20 weeks. To knowingly force someone to carry a baby to term when they know it’s not going to survive, I think, is cruel.”

The counter to that concern about state-imposed cruelty toward a pregnant mother?

State Representative Brent Crane, R-Nampa: the “hand of the Almighty ... His ways are higher than our ways,” Crane said. “He has the ability to take difficult, tragic, horrific circumstances and then turn them into wonderful examples.”

Sine die, meaning "without day," except not really. They'll be back next January, to do it all again.