Nov 04 2009

Angles on R-71

Published by Randy Stapilus at 2:19 pm under Washington

As of this afternoon, the vote on Washington Referendum 71 – whether to sustain the state law providing “everything but marriage” for same-sex domestic partnerships – continues close but has been holding steady, at 51% yes, 49% no. The potential for a flip remains, but the odds are growing that the voters will have upheld the law.

What that vote means depends on a considerable degree on what lessons you can to extract. One lesson, for example: The fact that “everything but marriage” was so close suggests that a vote on actual marriage would have lost, though probably not overwhelmingly, but much as it did in Maine.

What lessons might be drawn on a larger scale?

Oregonian political writer Jeff Mapes blogs that “Tuesday was a pretty good day for opponents of same-sex marriage.” Bearing in mind that Oregon gay rights activists are planning a gay marriage measure for the 2012 ballot, and the indication that domestic partnerships may be more acceptable territory than marriage, Mapes suggests that “Tuesday night’s returns will, at a minimum, throw up a big yellow caution flag for gay-rights advocates.”

Maybe more compelling, though, is the reaction this morning from Seattle Times columnist Danny Westneat, who sees a different significance in the vote: “It appears Washington state will be the first in America to approve a gay-equality measure not by court fiat or legislative action, but by the direct will of the people. It’s never happened before. If the slim lead holds for the gay-partnership law Referendum 71, it would be a landmark. Huge. . . no state has ever approved a pro-gay vote.”

He points to the example of a 1997 Washington state vote rejecting – with 59.7% majority – a ban on discriminating against gays. (The ballot title was: “Shall discrimination based on sexual orientation be prohibited in employment, employment agency, and union membership practices, without requiring employee partner benefits or preferential treatment?”) After yesterday’s vote, you suspect that such a ballot issue would have gone decisively the other way this year.

Westneat: “The take-away: The gay-rights movement has won over to its side 10 to 12 percent of this state in the past dozen years. That’s about 1 percent per year. That may not seem like much. But sweeping political change occurs when the center 5 or 10 percent shifts to the other side.”

Comments Off

Comments are closed at this time.


    Randy Stapilus talks about the Idaho Legislature 8:20 Monday mornings on KLIX-AM. Podcasts from this year are available.


    blog advertising is good for you

    50 Meds

    ORDER IT HERE or on Amazon.com

    More about this book by Randy Stapilus

    One or two won't do. Most books (articles, speeches) about fixing America's health care mess address two or three very real problems and solutions but not the waterfront, and our medical problem is too complex for cure by only a single silver bullet or two. This book for the first time compiles an extensive list of changes, some of them simple and some complex, that could cut costs and re-wire our system so it works better for all Americans. 50 ideas in a short and easy read - just 168 pages packed with solutions that can work. Available now from Ridenbaugh Press, $13.95

    Upstream

    ORDER HERE or Amazon.com

    The Snake River Basin Adjudication is one of the largest water adjudications the United States has ever seen, and it may be the most successful. Here's how it happened, from the pages of the SRBA Digest, for 16 years the independent source on the massive case - advances, slips, false starts and unexpected leaps.

    Paradox Politics

    ORDER HERE or Amazon.com

    After 21 years, a 2nd edition. If you're interested in Idaho politics and never read the original, now's the time. If you've read the original, here's perspective from now.



Technorati Profile